Comprehensive Analysis on Workman issue
Note :- Dear PTCL friends I have prepared a copmprensive note throug AI ChatGpt what does the “The Workmen’s Compensation Act, 1923
THE WORKMEN’S COMPENSATION ACT, 1923 (VIII of 1923)
[10 March 1923] says about about workman issue in connection with PTCL ,who are manipulating wrongly as informed by Adv Rana Hassan in his recently audio massage through YouTube .
Regards
Tariq
Date the 20th Nov 2026
Here is the reply of AI ChatGpt to whom I sent the photo copies of some relevant portions of the Act
A I ChatGpt
Dear Mr Tariq,
I have reproduced the main legal text visible in your photographs below, followed by my analysis of its relevance to PTCL employees and pensioners.
My principal conclusion is this: The photographs do not say that every employee in Grades 1 to 16 is a “workman.” They identify particular kinds of employment and duties. However, the Supreme Court’s majority judgment of 10 July 2025 did draw a distinction between employees who were civil servants at the time of transfer and employees legally classified as workmen. It also sent some cases back to the High Courts for their employment status to be determined.
Therefore, an employee’s grade alone should not settle the question. Equally, the fact that an employee was permanent, received a government salary or later received a pension does not automatically settle it either. The applicable law and the employee’s actual service record must be examined.
⸻
Part 1: Text reproduced from your photographs
A. The Workmen’s Compensation Act, 1923
THE WORKMEN’S COMPENSATION ACT, 1923
(VIII of 1923)
[10 March 1923]
An Act to provide for the payment by certain classes of employers to their workmen of compensation for injury by accident.
WHEREAS it is expedient to provide for the payment by certain classes of employers to their workmen of compensation for injury by accident; It is hereby enacted as follows:—
CHAPTER I
Preliminary
1. Short title, extent and commencement.—
(1) This Act may be called the Workmen’s Compensation Act, 1923.
(2) It extends to the whole of [the Punjab].
(3) It shall come into force on the first day of July, 1924.
2. Definitions.—
(1) In this Act, unless there is anything repugnant in the subject or context,—
(a) “adult” and “minor” mean respectively a person who is not and a person who is under the age of fifteen years;
(b) “Commissioner” means a Commissioner for Workmen’s Compensation appointed under section 20;
(c) “compensation” means compensation as provided for by this Act;
(d) “dependent” means any of the following relatives of a deceased workman, namely:—
(i) a widow, minor legitimate son and unmarried legitimate daughter, or a widowed mother, and
(ii) if wholly or in part dependent on the earnings of the workman at the time of his death, a widower, a parent other than a widowed mother, a minor illegitimate son, an unmarried illegitimate daughter, a daughter legitimate or illegitimate if married and a minor or if widowed, a minor brother, an unmarried or widowed sister, a widowed daughter—
[The photograph ends in the middle of this sentence. The remaining words are not visible in the supplied image.]
Notes on this photograph
The photograph includes footnotes identifying the original publication of the Act and later amendments. The main text shown is the Punjab version: section 1(2) says that it extends to Punjab. The law applicable to a particular employee must be checked for the relevant place and time; the historical federal wording may also matter when determining status at transfer.
The complete definition of “workman” in section 2(1)(n) does not appear in the photographs. It refers to, among other things, employment in a capacity listed in Schedule II, subject to the statutory conditions. The official federal text is available in the Pakistan Code.
⸻
B. Schedule II: Persons included in the definition of workman
The photographs overlap. I have combined repeated text so that each passage appears once. Amendment marks and footnote numbers have been simplified; the words marked as omitted in the photographs are shown as [omitted].
SCHEDULE II
[See section 2(1)(n)]
List of persons who, subject to the provisions of section 2(1)(n), are included in the definition of workman.
The following persons are workmen within the meaning of section 2(1)(n) and subject to the provisions of that section, that is to say, any person who is—
(i) employed, otherwise than [omitted] on a railway, in connection with the operation or maintenance of a lift or a vehicle propelled by steam or other mechanical power or by electricity; or
(ii) employed, [omitted], in any premises wherein, or within the precincts whereof, on any one day of the preceding twelve months, ten or more persons have been employed in any manufacturing process, as defined in clause (g) of section 2 of the Factories Act, 1934, or in any kind of work whatsoever incidental to or connected with any such manufacturing process or with the article made, and steam, water or other mechanical power or electrical power is used [omitted]; or
(iii) employed in any place to which section 5 of the Factories Act, 1934 has been applied or for the purpose of making, altering, repairing, ornamenting, finishing or otherwise adapting for us, transport or sale any article or part of an article in any premises wherein or within precincts whereof on any one day of the preceding twelve months, fifty or more persons have been so employed; or
(iv) employed in the manufacture or handling of explosives in any premises wherein, or within the precincts whereof, on any one day of the preceding twelve months, ten or more persons have been so employed; or
(v) employed in any mine as defined in clause (f) of section 3 of the Mines Act, 1923, in any mining operation, or in any kind of work, [omitted] incidental to or connected with any mining operation or with the mineral obtained, or in any kind of work whatsoever below ground:
Provided that any excavation in which on no day of the preceding twelve months more than fifty persons have been employed or explosives have been used and whose depth from its highest to its lowest points does not exceed twenty feet, shall be deemed not to be a mine for purpose of this clause; or
(vi) [omitted]
(vii) [omitted]
(vii-a) [omitted]
(viii) employed in the construction, repair or demolition of—
(a) any building or structure; or
(b) any dam or embankment which is twenty feet or more in height from its lowest to its highest point; or
(c) any road, bridge, or tunnel; or
(d) [omitted]
(ix) employed in setting up, repairing maintaining, or taking down any telegraph or telephone line or post of any overhead electric line or cable or post of standard for the same; or
(x) employed [omitted] in the construction, working, repair or demolition of any aerial ropeway, canal pipeline, or sewer; or
(xi) employed in the service of any fire-brigade; or
(xii) employed upon railway as defined in clause (4) of section 3, and subsection (1) of section 148 of the Railways Act, 1890 (IX of 1890), either directly or through a sub-contractor, by a person fulfilling a contract with the railway administration; or
(xiii) employed as an inspector, mail guard, sorter or van peon in the Railway Mail Service, or employed in any occupation ordinarily involving out-door work in the [omitted] posts and Telegraphs Department; or
(xiii-a) [omitted]
(xiv) employed [omitted] in connection with operations for winning natural petroleum or natural gas; or
(xv) employed in any occupation involving blasting operation; or
(xvi) employed in the making of excavation in which on any one day of the preceding twelve months more than twenty-five persons have been employed or explosive have been used, or whose depth from its highest to its lowest point exceeds twenty feet; or
(xvii) employed in the operation of any ferry boat capable of carrying more than ten persons; or
(xviii) employed, [omitted] on any estate which is maintained for the purpose of growing cinchona, coffee, rubber or tea, and on which on any one day in the preceding twelve months twenty-five or more persons have been so employed; or
(xix) employed [omitted] in the generating, transforming, or supplying of electrical energy or in the generating or supplying of gas, or
(xx) employed in a lighthouse as defined in clause (d) of section 2 of the Lighthouse Act, 1927 (XVII of 1927); or
(xxi) employed in producing cinematograph pictures intended for public exhibition are in exhibiting such picture; or
(xxii) employed in the training, keeping or working of elephants or wild animals; or
(xxiii) employed in the tapping of palm-trees or the felling or logging of trees, or the transport of timber by inland waters, or the control or extinguishing of forest fires; or
(xxiv) employed in operations for the catching or hunting of elephants or other wild animals; or
(xxv) employed as a driver:
(xxvi) employed in the handling or transport of goods in, or within the precinct of,—
(a) any warehouse or other place in which goods are stored, and in which on any one day of the preceding twelve months ten or more persons have been so employed, or
(b) any market in which on any one day of the preceding twelve months one hundred or more persons have been so employed; or
(xxvii) employed in any occupation involving the handling and manipulation of radium or X-rays apparatus, or contact with radioactive substances.
Explanation.— In this Schedule “the preceding twelve months” relates in any particular case to the twelve months ending with the day on which the accident in such case occurred.
(xxviii) employed as drivers, cleaners, conductors and checkers by Road Transport Service as defined in Sub-section (7) of section 2 of the Road Transport Workers Ordinance, 1961 (Ordinance XXVIII of 1961).
Transcription note: I have retained apparent wording or printing errors visible in the photographs, including “for us” in clause (iii) and “are in exhibiting” in clause (xxi). The photographs also contain amendment-history footnotes, which I have not reproduced word for word. The photographs are extracts, not the complete Act.
⸻
Part 2: What does “workman” mean for a PTCL employee?
1. The Act looks at specified work and statutory conditions
The Workmen’s Compensation Act is principally concerned with compensation for qualifying injury arising from employment. Its definition must be read together with the listed occupations in Schedule II and the other applicable conditions.
Two clauses in your photographs are particularly relevant to the former T&T Department:
Provision Work described Possible relevance
Schedule II, clause (ix) Setting up, repairing, maintaining or taking down telegraph or telephone lines and associated posts or cables May apply to an employee engaged in the specified line work, depending on the applicable version and facts.
Schedule II, clause (xiii) An occupation ordinarily involving outdoor work in the Posts and Telegraphs Department May be relevant to a former departmental employee whose occupation ordinarily involved such outdoor work.
These clauses do not say that every employee of the T&T Department or PTCL was a workman. Nor do the photographed clauses create a general rule that every person in Grades 1–16 was a workman.
For example:
• A person whose actual occupation involved maintaining telephone lines may fall within a relevant provision, subject to its terms.
• A person whose occupation ordinarily involved outdoor work in the former Posts and Telegraphs Department may fall within clause (xiii), subject to its terms.
• An office employee should not automatically be placed within clause (xiii) merely because that person worked for the department or held a particular grade. The actual occupation and applicable law must be considered.
• A title such as “clerk,” “technician,” “supervisor” or “officer” is useful evidence, but the legal answer also depends on the duties and the statutory provision being applied.
The Supreme Court has considered the outdoor-work provision in the context of the civil-servant definition and service-tribunal jurisdiction. That makes this a serious legal question, not merely an informal employment label.
2. A regular government employee may still be called a workman for a legal purpose
This is the difficult point.
A person could be a regular or permanent employee of a government department and still fall within the definition of “workman” under a particular law. The words describe different matters:
• Regular or permanent employee concerns the nature of the appointment.
• Government employee identifies the employer or department.
• Workman has a statutory meaning for the purpose of the relevant law.
• Civil servant is also a statutory category with its own definition and exclusions.
Therefore, an employee can say, truthfully:
“I was a permanent employee of the government’s T&T Department.”
But whether that employee was also a civil servant for the purpose of the 2025 pension judgment requires a separate legal examination. The Civil Servants Act’s definition excluded persons who fell within certain statutory definitions of worker or workman. The applicable historical wording and the employee’s duties therefore matter.
Receiving government pay, allowances or a pension is important evidence. By itself, however, it does not conclusively prove civil-servant status or a right to every later government pension increase.
Likewise, being called a workman does not, by itself, prove that the person never had a pension or that every benefit can lawfully be withdrawn.
⸻
Part 3: What did the Supreme Court decide on 10 July 2025?
The case is reported as Pakistan Telecommunication Company Ltd. v. Imran Aziz and others, Civil Appeal No. 1509 of 2021 and connected matters.
The Court decided the cases by a majority of two judges to one. The operative order adopted the judgment of Chief Justice Yahya Afridi. Justice Ayesha A. Malik wrote the other opinion; it should not be treated as the binding majority where the two opinions differ.
A. Protection for transferred former civil servants
The majority held that relevant employees transferred from T&T to PTC and then PTCL did not continue to hold their civil-servant status after transfer. Nevertheless, the governing statutory framework protected their existing pensionary rights.
For employees who were civil servants at the time of transfer, the majority recognised the continuing and evolving character of the protected pension entitlement, including the relevant pension revisions notified by the Federal Government.
The final order expressly upheld pension revisions for transferred employees who were civil servants at the time of transfer. It dismissed, among others, CPLA Nos. 6023–6030 and 6087–6096 of 2021.
This is relevant to your own history as a respondent in CPLA 6023/2021 and 6095/2021, although the effect on any particular respondent must always be read with the actual case record and any subsequent order.
B. The majority did distinguish workmen from civil servants
I must be candid on this point, Mr Tariq. The majority did not simply declare that all former T&T employees, including all workmen, were automatically entitled to the same government pension increases.
The majority discussed a distinction between:
1. Employees who had the relevant statutory pension rights as civil servants at the time of transfer; and
2. Employees legally classified as workmen whose existing terms did not include the same enforceable right to the claimed increases.
It considered that the nature of the pre-existing entitlement mattered. In some cases, the Court dismissed claims because, among other reasons stated in its order, the employees had not established the necessary civil-servant status or statutory entitlement.
That does not mean PTCL can lawfully classify a person as a workman without establishing the factual and legal basis. Nor does the judgment say that a grade number alone settles that status.
C. Some cases were sent back for a factual decision
The Supreme Court remanded certain matters to the relevant High Courts to determine the employees’ classification or status at the time of transfer. In specified matters, the order stated that, if the employees were found to have been civil servants, they would be entitled to the relevant continuation of pension benefits and revisions.
This is a strong reason to insist on individual, evidence-based classification.
It also means that one should not tell every Grade 1–16 employee that their pension-increase claim has already succeeded. Their case may depend on their duties, records, applicable law, the court order in their particular case and any later decision.
⸻
Part 4: Is PTCL correct to treat all Grade 1–16 employees as workmen?
On the material available to me, I cannot establish that PTCL has issued a general written rule saying that every Grade 1–16 employee is a workman. You have informed me that PTCL is taking this position, and it is a matter that deserves a clear written answer.
What I can say is:
A classification based only on Grade 1–16 would need a clear legal basis. The provisions photographed by you do not themselves establish such a blanket grade-based rule.
A fair examination should ask:
1. What was the employee’s original appointment and department?
2. Was the appointment regular, temporary, contractual or otherwise?
3. What post did the employee hold at the relevant time before transfer?
4. What duties did the employee actually perform?
5. Did those duties bring the employee within a particular statutory definition of workman or worker?
6. What pension rights and service terms existed before transfer?
7. What do the individual transfer order, pension documents and any applicable court orders say?
8. Is there a later judgment or review order affecting that particular case?
The answer may differ between employees in the same grade, because their duties and service records may differ. Conversely, a grade alone does not establish that an employee is outside the statutory definition.
Government benefits during service
The fact that an employee received government pay scales, increments, leave and other benefits is relevant and should be documented. It may help establish the nature of the employment and the employee’s pre-transfer rights.
But PTCL may argue—and the Court may have to decide—that a person was a government employee while still falling within a workman exclusion from the statutory definition of civil servant.
For that reason, the strongest approach is not to rely on salary slips alone. It is to present the whole service history and the actual nature of the employee’s work.
⸻
Part 5: PTCL’s position and its attitude towards pensioners
PTCL’s own 2025 annual report records its interpretation of the 10 July 2025 judgment. It states that former T&T civil servants are eligible for the relevant government pension increases, while employees categorised as workmen or workers are not eligible for those increases under the position it describes. The report also acknowledges that some cases were remanded to the High Courts for determination of civil-servant or workman status.
That is evidence of PTCL’s stated position. It should be distinguished from proof that PTCL has correctly classified every individual pensioner.
In my assessment, PTCL’s conduct would be open to serious challenge if it:
• Rejects a pensioner solely because the person held Grade 1–16, without identifying the statutory provision and relevant duties;
• Refuses to examine the service record or ignores evidence favourable to the pensioner;
• Treats the label “workman” as automatically cancelling a pension or another benefit without identifying the governing law;
• Applies an adverse classification without giving reasons; or
• Fails to comply with a court order that applies to the individual concerned.
Such an approach would be difficult for pensioners to understand and contest. It could also produce unfair results where employees with different duties are placed in one group merely because of grade.
At the same time, PTCL’s reliance on a civil-servant/workman distinction is not automatically contrary to the 2025 majority judgment, because the majority itself drew a legal distinction. The strongest challenge is therefore to a wrong or unsupported classification, an incorrect application of the judgment, or non-compliance with an order—not to assume that the Court removed the distinction altogether.
⸻
Part 6: What affected pensioners can do
An affected employee or pensioner can submit a written representation to PTCL and PTET asking for a reasoned individual decision.
The representation can request:
1. A copy of the rule, notification or order under which PTCL considers the employee a workman.
2. The precise statutory definition and Schedule II clause relied upon.
3. The employee’s duties and the date on which PTCL says the workman classification applied.
4. Copies of the documents used to reach that conclusion.
5. An explanation of how the 10 July 2025 judgment and any order in the employee’s own case were applied.
6. A review of the decision in light of the appointment letter, service book, duty record, transfer documents and pension record.
7. A pension calculation showing the amount paid and the increases allowed or refused.
Useful documents include the original T&T appointment letter, service book, descriptions of duties, promotion and transfer orders, pay records, retirement order, pension payment order, pension calculations, any PTCL/PTET refusal, and the judgment or order naming the employee.
If the representation is rejected, the appropriate next step—such as a pending High Court case, a fresh proceeding, or an application for enforcement—depends on the person’s existing case and the applicable order. A lawyer should check those documents before choosing the forum.
Suggested wording for pensioners
“I respectfully request PTCL and PTET to determine my status on the basis of my appointment, actual duties, service record and applicable law. Please identify the precise statutory provision under which I have been classified as a workman and explain how that classification affects my pension entitlement.
My considered view: Pensioners in Grades 1–16 should not lose hope. Some may have a substantial case that they were wrongly classified, or that their particular pension rights were not correctly considered. But each claim must be supported by the employee’s records and assessed against the binding judgment and any later order applicable to that person.
Comments