Corruption in Pakistan



Corruption in Pakistan: The Loss of National Wealth, PTCL’s Privatisation and the Road to Reform
By Muhammad Tariq Azhar
Rawalpindi
Date 21-11-2026

Pakistan is a country blessed by Almighty Allah with natural resources, a capable workforce and hardworking people. Our farmers cultivate the land, our workers build roads and buildings, our traders and industrialists support the economy, and our young people demonstrate their abilities around the world.

Yet an ordinary Pakistani often asks: if our country has so much potential, why are education, healthcare, justice, employment and basic services still inadequate for so many people? Why do inflation and debt place such a heavy burden on the public? Why do national institutions and development projects repeatedly face financial and administrative difficulties?

These questions have several economic, political and administrative answers. One important cause, however, is corruption, the misuse of authority and a lack of effective accountability over public resources.

Corruption is not limited to a person directly giving or taking a bribe. Public governance is also damaged when decisions are made for private benefit instead of the national interest, when favouritism replaces merit, when public money is spent without proper accountability, or when weak oversight allows an individual or company to receive an unlawful advantage.

Fairness also requires us to acknowledge that not every government employee, officer or institution is corrupt. Pakistan has many honest people who perform their duties under difficult conditions. They deserve respect and the protection needed to work without improper pressure.

How public money can be wasted

The government collects resources through taxes, fees and other sources. These resources are used for roads, bridges, schools, hospitals, electricity, water and other public services. Every rupee in the public treasury is therefore held in trust for the people.

Opportunities for corruption can arise when a project budget is inflated, tender conditions are designed for a favoured company, competition is restricted, poor-quality materials are used, or payment is approved before work has been properly completed.

There are also public complaints that illegal commissions are demanded at different stages of awarding contracts or releasing project funds. Every such complaint deserves serious attention and an independent investigation based on evidence. It would not be fair to declare a particular institution or individual guilty without proof.

A hypothetical example can explain the risk. Suppose Rs 100 crore is allocated to build a road, but Rs 20 crore is lost through illegal commissions or other irregularities. Less money would remain for the project. The contractor must still purchase materials, pay workers and earn a profit. This may increase the risk of poor-quality materials being used or essential work being reduced.

The road could then deteriorate early, requiring further spending from the public treasury. Citizens would pay repeatedly for the same project without receiving the service they were promised.

This is an example for illustration. It is not a proven allegation against a particular project or institution. A proper assessment of a real project requires examination of its budget, tender, contract, payments, quality of work and audit report.

The burden on ordinary citizens

The effects of corruption are not confined to major contracts. An ordinary citizen may also pay the price.

An elderly person may visit an office to correct a pension payment; another citizen may need a land transfer or an official document; a patient may seek treatment at a government hospital; and a young person may apply for a job on merit. These are legitimate rights. If unnecessary obstacles are created and a bribe or improper recommendation is demanded to remove them, confidence in the law is weakened.

Not every delay, however, is caused by corruption. Staff shortages, inaccurate records, poor administration or complicated rules can also create difficulties. The real cause should therefore be identified in each case.

Where an official has deliberately misused authority, an expression of regret is not enough. There should be an investigation and appropriate action in accordance with law.

The damage caused by favouritism

Favouritism and nepotism are also serious concerns. When appointments, promotions, transfers or contracts are decided on the basis of personal connections instead of ability, transparency and rules, deserving people lose opportunities and institutions become weaker.

An unsuitable person placed in an important position can increase the risk of poor decisions, while capable and hardworking people become discouraged. An honest officer may also find it difficult to perform properly if pleasing an influential person appears more important than following the law.

Public confidence will grow when an ordinary citizen believes that an application, employment opportunity, business matter or legal case will be decided on merit and law rather than status and connections.

PTCL’s privatisation: an important national example

The privatisation of Pakistan Telecommunication Company Limited, or PTCL, is an important example in a discussion of public resources, major agreements and government accountability. I also raised questions about it in my article dated 10 November 2015.

My purpose is not to treat a weakness in an agreement, or a national dispute, as automatic proof that an individual accepted a bribe or committed a crime. My demand is that, when national wealth and the public interest are involved, the important facts should be presented openly and investigated independently where necessary.

On 18 June 2005, bidding was held for the sale of 26 per cent of PTCL’s shares, together with management control. A bidder led by Etisalat submitted the highest offer: US$1.96 per share, making the total bid approximately US$2.599 billion. It was a major privatisation transaction for Pakistan.

Discussions later took place concerning the payment arrangements. Under the structure agreed in 2006, approximately US$1.4 billion was paid initially, and the balance was to be paid in nine half-yearly instalments. Despite later payments, approximately US$800 million became the subject of a dispute.

An important question is what effect the changes made after the bid to the payment structure and other relevant terms had on the national interest, government revenue and equal treatment of other bidders.

A change cannot automatically be declared illegal or criminal simply because it occurred after bidding. However, if the change was significant, the public should know why it was made, which authorised body approved it and how its consequences were assessed.

In my view, the answer requires a comparison of the original bidding conditions, the relevant agreements, later changes and official approvals.

Questions concerning earnest money and properties

According to the official bidding record, eligible bidders were required to submit US$40 million each as earnest money.

It is reasonable to ask what the earnest-money and bid-validity conditions required when difficulties arose between the successful bidder and the government over payment and the agreement, and what legal advice the government obtained at that time.

Whether the earnest money could or should lawfully have been forfeited at any particular stage cannot be determined without examining the original documents, extensions, relevant approvals and applicable law.

Another dispute arose over the transfer of title to certain properties associated with PTCL. Available reports state that the government was required to arrange clear title to the relevant properties in PTCL’s name. Etisalat cited incomplete transfers of certain properties as a reason for withholding the outstanding payment.

An important distinction must be maintained: transferring property to PTCL is not the same as transferring it directly to Etisalat. The relevant Etisalat company obtained a 26 per cent shareholding and management control in PTCL.

My question is whether the risk was properly assessed if transfers of some properties were difficult because of incomplete records, provincial ownership claims or legal disputes. It is also necessary to know what procedure the agreement provided concerning the outstanding payment or property values if transfer remained incomplete.

These questions can only be answered properly by examining the original record.

The Public Accounts Committee and the outstanding US$800 million

In May 2015, the National Assembly’s Public Accounts Committee discussed PTCL’s privatisation, weaknesses in the agreement and the outstanding payment. Reporting from that time stated that relevant officials and a NAB representative also identified problems concerning the agreement.

This shows that serious questions existed. However, a contractual weakness, poor planning or possible loss arising from a condition is different from proof of bribery or a criminal conspiracy by a particular individual. Maintaining that distinction is essential for both fairness and credible accountability.

According to reporting available up to November 2026, the dispute over approximately US$800 million remained unresolved. Reports also stated that the government was considering legal options, including international arbitration, alongside negotiations.

The government should explain clearly to the public and Parliament what Pakistan’s position is, what steps have been taken, and what legal route may be pursued.

The possible financial effect of delay on the public treasury should also be examined. However, any claim for interest, damages or an additional amount must be determined under the relevant agreement, law and legal decision.

Rights of transferred employees and pensioners

An important aspect of the PTCL matter concerns its employees and pensioners, particularly those who moved from the Telegraph and Telephone Department to the Pakistan Telecommunication Corporation and later to PTCL.

Their terms of service and pension-related rights have been considered under specific laws and court decisions. Cases such as Masood Bhatti and PTET v Muhammad Arif considered legal protections for transferred employees and pensioners.

Many pensioners complained that they did not receive payments in accordance with pension increases announced by the Federal Government and had to approach the courts to pursue their rights.

My position is that an employee or pensioner whose rights are protected under the applicable law and court order should not have to make repeated visits to offices and courts to obtain a lawful entitlement. The government, PTCL and PTET should fulfil their respective legal responsibilities.

At the same time, each person’s case must be assessed in light of their employment, transfer, retirement, applicable rules and the court order that applies to them. Justice requires that each entitled person receive the correct benefit.

Investigations must respect evidence and fairness

Whenever a major agreement or public project raises suspicion of irregularity, the relevant institutions should obtain the necessary records and conduct an impartial investigation.

In a matter such as PTCL’s privatisation, the investigation should examine:

• Whether the bidding and agreement complied with the applicable laws and rules;
• What the original conditions were, what changed later and who approved the changes;
• How much was known in advance about difficulties in transferring properties;
• What safeguards or legal remedies existed to protect the outstanding payment;
• Whether any person or institution received an unlawful advantage;
• If an unlawful action or improper decision caused national loss, who was responsible.

If evidence is found against an individual, action should follow according to law. If an allegation is not established, that person’s innocence must also be respected. The purpose of a transparent investigation is to discover the truth, not to prove a conclusion decided in advance.

How corruption affects national development

When public resources are not used properly, the damage appears in many forms.

A poorly built road may fail early. Wasted hospital resources can contribute to shortages of medicines and facilities. Inadequate spending on schools affects children’s education. Favouritism in employment discourages capable young people. Unclear terms or weak oversight in major agreements can place a long-term burden on the national treasury.

Corruption can also damage business confidence. If an investor or trader believes decisions depend on connections and uncertain discretion instead of clear law, investment and economic activity may suffer.

This does not mean corruption is the only cause of Pakistan’s economic problems. Weak planning, administrative shortcomings, political instability, debt and other factors also matter. But corruption and weak accountability can make those problems more severe.

A 2025 International Monetary Fund assessment linked corruption risks in Pakistan to weaknesses in oversight, public procurement and the capacity and independence of accountability institutions.

How can Pakistan reduce corruption?

Speeches and slogans alone are not enough. We need practical measures that reduce opportunities for wrongdoing, preserve a record of official decisions, make irregularities easier to detect and ensure that complaints receive a fair response.

First: make public project information available

For every major project, the public should be able to see, in simple language, the approved budget, how the tender was awarded, which company won, when work was due to be completed and how much has been paid.

Important later changes to a contract should also be recorded and explained. Where information cannot lawfully be released, the reason should be stated.

This would allow the public, Parliament, auditors and the media to see how public money is being used.

Second: make procurement transparent

Public procurement records should be maintained electronically so that it is possible to determine who prepared conditions, when bids were submitted, why a decision was made and what changes were made to the contract.

Pakistan already has the e-Pak Acquisition and Disposal System, or e-PADS. Effective use of the system, independent review of its records and timely action on complaints can help improve transparency.

However, merely keeping records on a computer will not end corruption. The information must be accurate, oversight must be effective, and breaches of rules must lead to appropriate action.

Third: verify work before payment

Payments for large construction projects should be made in stages, with independent checks at each stage.

For example, road construction should be checked for the quality of materials, required thickness, drainage and other technical standards. Inspection reports should be preserved, and defective work should be corrected under the contract.

This can connect payments from the treasury to real work of the required quality.

Fourth: act on audit findings

The public often hears that an audit has raised objections about a department or project, but later does not learn what happened.

A department should respond to audit observations within a defined period. Where an improper payment is established, recovery should be pursued according to law. Where evidence of a crime is found, the appropriate investigative institution should act.

The public should also be informed which major audit objections were resolved, which remained outstanding and what action followed.

Fifth: protect honest employees and people who report wrongdoing

An employee or citizen who reports suspected corruption in good faith with evidence should receive appropriate protection against threats, harassment, retaliatory transfer or loss of employment.

A person accused of wrongdoing must also have a full opportunity to respond, present documents and receive a fair hearing.

A system cannot deliver justice if honest people are afraid to speak and accused persons are denied the right to defend themselves.

Sixth: apply accountability equally

The standard of accountability should not change according to an individual’s office, political affiliation, influence or wealth. Where credible evidence exists, an investigation should proceed according to law, however powerful the person may be.

Accountability institutions need professional capacity, adequate resources and independence within the law. Their own performance must also be subject to oversight so that accountability does not become a tool for political or personal purposes.

Seventh: establish merit in employment and promotion

Clear criteria should govern recruitment, promotion, transfers and important public appointments. Reasons for decisions should be recorded, and affected persons should have a suitable right to complain or appeal.

When honest and capable people have a fair opportunity to advance, institutional performance and public confidence can improve.

Eighth: make public services simple and clear

For pensions, land records, licences, bills and other public services, the required documents, official fees, procedures and expected processing times should be clearly stated.

Every applicant should receive a receipt or tracking number. If there is a delay, the reason should be communicated, and an accessible complaint and appeal process should exist.

When citizens understand their rights and the official procedure, it becomes harder to demand improper payments.

Ninth: Parliament, the media and citizens must play their part

Parliamentary committees should seriously examine public spending, national agreements and audit reports. The media should raise questions of public interest responsibly and with evidence.

Citizens and public-interest organisations should be able to use lawful means to obtain information, monitor projects and report suspected irregularities. They should also consider the relevant party’s response and the available evidence before making allegations.

Tenth: promote ethical responsibility and leadership by example

Laws and oversight are necessary, but honesty must also be valued in society. Families, educational institutions, offices and political leaders influence others through their conduct.

When people in senior positions treat public money as a trust, explain their decisions and obey the law, their example can have a positive effect throughout the system.

My appeal to fellow Pakistanis

Dear fellow Pakistanis,

Corruption did not develop in one day, and it cannot be eliminated in one day. But it would also be wrong to remain silent on the assumption that nothing can be done.

If we demand transparent decisions, independent oversight, merit, timely justice and equal accountability—and practise honesty in our own lives—we can significantly reduce opportunities for corruption.

In PTCL’s privatisation and every other major national matter, our principle should be the same: the facts must be disclosed, the national interest protected, the law followed, and responsibility determined on the basis of evidence.

We must build a Pakistan where an ordinary citizen does not need a bribe, improper recommendation or an influential person’s support to obtain a lawful service; where the terms of national agreements are clear; where the legal rights of employees and pensioners are respected; and where public money is truly spent for public welfare.

National wealth is a trust shared by all of us. Protecting it is a responsibility of government and a right of every citizen.

Muhammad Tariq Azhar
Rawalpindi

Date: 21-11-2026

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Article-170[ Regarding Article -137 Part -1 in English]

.....آہ ماں۔

Article-173 Part-2 [Draft for non VSS-2008 optees PTCL retired employees]